Women and Biology: Reality’s Last Stand – Dr. Mike Bird


Women, Biology, and British Politics

British Labour Has a “Women” problem, in that, they don’t seem to think that they actually exist!

Watch this video by UK opposition leader Sir Keir Starmer (British Labour Party) on why it’s wrong to say that only women have a cervix. The funny thing is, he can’t explain it!

This kind of stuff terrifies me.

I understand that:

  • Gender is a social construct about roles and expectations for men and women in a given culture.
  • Some people are non-binary and don’t identify with the either/or of gender stereotypes.
  • Some people are intersex – a complex series of developmental sex disorders – so that their biological in rare cases can be complex.
  • Some people have gender dysphoria and wish to present in another gender to alleviate mental anguish.
  • Some people have experienced abuse, alienation, and discrimination because of their gender, sex, or self-presentation.
  • We should have a network of rights to prevent discrimination and harm against people who are non-binary, transgender, intersex, etc.

However, what I don’t understand is:

  • The denial that human beings are a sexually dimorphic species who reproduce by the production and union of large and small gemmates.
  • The denial that women’s rights are for biological women, not for people who think/feel they are women.
  • The politicization and tribalization of human biology.
  • The reduction of personal “identity” to a mixture of sexual desire and individual personality when there are so many other aspects of human existence that contribute to who we are as individual persons.
  • The demand to make private self-identification a state-enforced dogma requiring mandatory public assent.
  • The attacks on anyone who raises questions about the dangers of the premature transitioning of adolescents.
  • The “cotton ceiling” whereby Lesbians are “transphobic” if they refuse to have sexual relations with a trans-woman with a penis.
  • The aggressive anthropological monism that tries to erase the biological differences between human beings.

A Personal Story

To be open and honest, I have a son on the autism spectrum and autistic persons are more likely to experience gender dysphoria and to identify as transgender. There’s a few sides to this, such as whether autistics sometimes have brains that are configured in such a way that defies the male-female binary, or whether autistics have difficulties at negotiating social ambiguities which make them susceptible to interpret their confusion about adolescents and personal identity as trans. Either way, precisely because autistic persons have a susceptibility/high-representation as transgender, I am naturally inclined to sympathy and support.

We should not have to choose between respect and rights for trans-persons and basic women’s rights, but we are sadly being forced to do so. An affirmation of non-binary and transgender persons should not require a reinterpretation of human biology let alone the erasure of women as a biological category.

Reality’s Last Stand

Ultimately the debate about whether “women have a cervix” is a debate about the nature of reality. Is reality merely a mess of power-grabbing ideologies that need to be deconstructed? Or, does reality consist, in part at least, of empirical observations which are true and independent of any ideology?

Is truth, even scientific truth, merely a piece of spin to be spun according to the persuasion and power of the mob with the loudest voice or the person carrying the biggest club?

Are the barest of biological facts now to be ambiguated, denied, and then reassembled by an elite class who enforce their anthropological monistic dogmas by a rainbow inquisition bent on eradicating all dissent or even advocacy for women qua women?

Forgive my rant, but I believe that this is – to use Colin Wright’s memorable phrase – reality’s last stand. If we cannot stand up and defend the most basic of biological truths without fear of reprisal, that only women have a cervix, then we are headed into an Orwellian world where the only truth is what serves tribal and political ends, everything else is blasphemy.

The government that orders us to confess that men can have a cervix, and will punish us for dissenting, is the same government that can force us to accept that:

  • There is no famine in the Ukraine.
  • There is no AIDS in Romania.
  • There are no Americans in Baghdad.
  • Iraq has weapons of mass destruction.
  • Two plus two equals five.

That’s why I have memorized some important quotes, and so should you!

  • “Live not by lies.” Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
  • “Great is truth and it shall prevail.” 1 Esdras 4.35, 41
  • “The heresy of heresies was common sense.” George Orwell
  • “Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two make four.” George Orwell

Things to Read

For the opposite view, read the NYT piece Why Sex is non-Binary.

There’s a great rejoinder to this type of thinking by Colin Wright, Sex is Not a Spectrum.

On children and transgenderism, read Michelle Moore and Heather Brunskell Evans, Transgender Children and Young People with my own summary and review here.

Also worth reading are:

Kathleen Stock, Material Girls: Why Reality Matters for Feminism.

Debra Soh, The End of Gender: Debunking the Myths about Sex and Gender.

Michael F. Bird

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s